Please login to the form below

Not currently logged in
Email:
Password:

Hospitals' self-certification is flawed

Sixty per cent of English hospitals are providing misleading performance assessments according to a BBC documentary

The majority of hospitals are not assessing their own performance accurately, according to a Panorama investigation. The BBC documentary, aired last night, found that 60 per cent of inspected hospitals in England were providing misleading performance assessments.

The programme makers say that they based their findings on figures from the government's own health regulator, the Care Quality Commission (CQC). The CQC told them that no self assessment was "ever accepted at face value" after discrepancies were found between hospital-provided information and its own findings.

Checks revealed that three out of the four core areas were misreported in Peterborough, Southport and Ormskirk. Two out of four core areas were misreported in East Cheshire, Maidstone, Medway, West Hertfordshire, Weston area and Mid Staffordshire.

Last month, an inquiry into Stafford Hospital by medical intelligence company Dr Foster reported patients had been caused "unimaginable distress and suffering" as a result of "appalling" care. However the BBC documentary revealed the hospital had rated itself as 'fair' for most of the time.

Health minister Mike O'Brien said the way hospitals are rated and monitored is being changed: The system "was flawed and that's why we have changed it. And that is why we are now in a position where we don't rely on self assessment… it is subject to a whole series of checks."

The CQC said a more rigorous checking system will come into force in April. A spokesman told the BBC: "We will be using our data sources to monitor trusts' performance on a continual, even day-to-day basis, and we will have the flexibility to carry out announced checks whenever we feel there is a particular concern."

9th March 2010

Share

Featured jobs

Subscribe to our email news alerts

PMHub

Add my company
infill healthcare communication

infill is a dynamic and innovative, international healthcare agency with >25 years' experience in delivering healthcare communication, medical education and...

Latest intelligence

Precision paediatrics: Treating patients with CAR-T
Dr Stuart Adams specialises in using T-cell therapy to treat paediatric patients at Great Ormond Street Hospital. Here, he explains what it was like to develop and deliver a groundbreaking...
What does it mean to be an agile organisation
We spoke with Philip Atkinson to learn how healthcare and pharmaceutical companies can rapidly respond to changes in the market....
Battling breast cancer with precision medicine (Part 2)
Dr Mark Moasser treated breast cancer survivor Laura Holmes-Haddad (interviewed in part one) with an innovative precision medicine, which at the time was yet to be approved. Here he gives...

Infographics