Please login to the form below

Not currently logged in

Novartis pulls R&D investment in India over Glivec patent ruling

Swiss pharmaceutical company Novartis has revealed it will withdraw significant planned R&D investments in India over the next few years as a result of the Indian Glivec (imatinib) patent ruling.

Swiss pharmaceutical company Novartis has revealed it will withdraw significant planned R&D investments in India over the next few years as a result of the Indian Glivec (imatinib) patent ruling.

In a Financial Times report, Novartis' CEO Daniel Vasella said that the company could no longer do business in a country where laws have weakened intellectual property protection on new medicines and would now transfer investment elsewhere.

In early August 2007, an Indian court rejected a challenge by Novartis to a law which denies patents for minor improvements to known drugs.

Novartis had appealed against an earlier Indian ruling to reject patents on its leukaemia drug Glivec. The court argued that incremental innovation did not qualify it as a new chemical entity justifying protection. The company countered by saying that the Indian patent system stifled innovation, such as making a drug resistant to heat or changing the formulation to oral delivery rather than an injection.

Incremental innovation is defined as an action which improves a currently delivered benefit, or a small change made to an existing product not only to keep it fresh in the eyes of customers, but also to extend its lifecycle. Companies often emphasise incremental innovation for good reason, as there are many pressures to produce benefits alongside the pressures of consistency and risk aversion.

Vasella said in an interview: "This ruling is not an invitation to invest in Indian research and development, which we would have done. We will invest more in countries where we have protection. It's not a punishment. It's just a question of the culture for investment."

Despite Vasella's comments, the Glivec case now sets a precedent among pharmaceutical companies seeking patent protection in countries that cannot afford to pay for branded drugs.

The Indian situation underscores the battle between multinational drug firms and humanitarian campaigners, such as Medecins Sans Frontiers, which claim that pharmaceutical companies are placing patent protection and profits ahead of patient access to drugs.

Other cases
US pharmaceutical company Abbott recently reduced the price of its HIV treatment Kaletra (lopinavir/ritonavir) paid by the Brazilian government by some 29.5 per cent in 2007 to USD 0.73.

Abbottís cooperation with Brazil came about when the government there threatened to compulsorily license Abbottís drug in 2005, although a compromise price was later settled.

Both Abbott and Merck have created specific pricing models for their ARV drugs in developing countries, but the Brazilian government has only accepted the formerís model. Bristol-Myers Squibb (BMS) recently agreed a new pricing system there.

Thailand has adopted the compulsory license procedure and is importing generic copies of US-manufactured HIV and cancer drugs. Abbott reacted to Thailand's position by withdrawing seven of its latest HIV drugs from the market there, but then went on to cut the price of Kaletra to around USD 1,000 per patient per year.

22nd August 2007


COVID-19 Updates and Daily News

Featured jobs


Add my company
Virgo Health

Virgo Health is an award-winning global healthcare communications and medical education agency. We dispense pioneering and creative campaigns, driven by...

Latest intelligence

DEMAND DIVERSITY REPORT 02: Why is the LGBTQ+ community facing poorer health outcomes due to COVID-19?
We’re all aware that clinical trials have been discussed more widely since the COVID-19 pandemic. While that’s a great thing for raising awareness of clinical trials in general, it’s also...
CHECKLIST 04: Let’s make your patient recruitment strategies a success
From how to generate insights to define your audience to drilling down those all-important key messages, our checklist has everything you need to think of, covered....
Multichannel engagement and the need for greater understanding of European markets
By Laurence Olding and Georgina James...