Please login to the form below
Are reverse auctions the best way to procure marketing services?
Managing Director Martin Brass discusses what a reverse auction is, and whether it truly is a good way for healthcare companies to drive efficiencies when procuring marketing services.
Many years ago I was invited by a friend, who was working at PWC at the
time, to a demo of an innovation in enterprise purchasing technology. I have to
be honest that at the time, Fred Bassett and I were working with
Robbie Williams and his managers developing a new strategy and business model
for music artists, so this invitation wasn’t exactly “rock and roll”.
Nonetheless, I decided to attend. What I experienced that day was a reverse
auction.
Fast forward 13 years. Blue Latitude Health is now a 70 person company with global and regional clients from some of the largest companies in the healthcare sector. These companies have developed very sophisticated procurement departments whose role is to purchase products and services in various categories at an optimal price.
Several weeks ago, I received an invitation from an agent of one of our clients to participate in an auction for market research services. On reading the small print I became aware that this was, in fact, a reverse auction. We had been selected as one of 20 or so companies to bid to become a preferred global partner for research services. What was being auctioned was our rate card. The two companies with the lowest average rate cards would be chosen to join their panel of vendors.
I was intrigued enough to accept the invitation and complete the comprehensive RFI documentation that would qualify us in or out of the process. However, it made me question whether a reverse auction would actually work for the procurement of services at all. Sure, if you are buying a commodity, where the quality of the product is standard (or within a range) then a reverse auction will simply choose the most efficient vendor. If the vendor is efficient and has a high profit margin, then they can afford to sell their product for a lower price. But services are different, right? Services are performed by people who are experienced and expertly trained and the output, or ‘product’, is not standard, and in the case of research, is often unknown!
![]()
Fast forward 13 years. Blue Latitude Health is now a 70 person company with global and regional clients from some of the largest companies in the healthcare sector. These companies have developed very sophisticated procurement departments whose role is to purchase products and services in various categories at an optimal price.
An invitation to race to the bottom
What is a reverse auction? Well, simply put, it is the same as an auction except that, instead of a group of buyers bidding up the price on an item, a group of vendors are bidding down the price. In a regular auction, the market value of an item is based on the highest price that a bidder is willing to pay for it. In a reverse auction, the value is decided by the lowest price that a vendor is willing to sell it for.Several weeks ago, I received an invitation from an agent of one of our clients to participate in an auction for market research services. On reading the small print I became aware that this was, in fact, a reverse auction. We had been selected as one of 20 or so companies to bid to become a preferred global partner for research services. What was being auctioned was our rate card. The two companies with the lowest average rate cards would be chosen to join their panel of vendors.
I was intrigued enough to accept the invitation and complete the comprehensive RFI documentation that would qualify us in or out of the process. However, it made me question whether a reverse auction would actually work for the procurement of services at all. Sure, if you are buying a commodity, where the quality of the product is standard (or within a range) then a reverse auction will simply choose the most efficient vendor. If the vendor is efficient and has a high profit margin, then they can afford to sell their product for a lower price. But services are different, right? Services are performed by people who are experienced and expertly trained and the output, or ‘product’, is not standard, and in the case of research, is often unknown!
Download the full article from Blue Latitude Health
Company Details
Blue Latitude Health
+44 203 328 1840
Address:
Blue Latitude Health (UK)
140 Aldersgate Street
London
EC1A 4HY
United Kingdom
Latest content on this profile
- What does the future hold for Medical Affairs?
- Lori Lush, Head of Fishawack Medical, reveals why she’s driven to tell impactful scientific stories, the benefits of cross-functional collaboration, and the trends she predicts for the next five years.
Blue Latitude Health
- Mistrust in medical research: a patient perspective
- The recent development of several COVID-19 vaccines has placed medical research firmly in the spotlight, highlighting public confusion and misinformation about clinical trials. Patient advocate, Trishna Bharadia reveals what the life sciences industry can do to rebuild trust.
Blue Latitude Health
- Real-world evidence: breaking boundaries in rare disease
- Generating data for drug launches is a challenging process. In rare diseases, with small patient populations and high unmet need, evidence generation is even more complex. Consultant Sarah Poole and Senior Consultant Craig Moore explore the benefits of using real-world evidence and the common pitfalls life science companies should avoid.
Blue Latitude Health
- The heavy toll of COVID-19 on cancer patients
- We all know that finding and treating cancer early saves lives. During the COVID-19 pandemic, oncology treatments paused while cancer continued to spread. So, what has been the impact of this lost time for patients?
Blue Latitude Health
- Unpacking rare diseases in the first edition of Delta magazine
- Fishawack Health launches Delta magazine with a deep dive into rare disease commercialization
Blue Latitude Health
- Great creative is effective creative. And effective creative is affective creative
- Our creative approach at Fishawack Health is Affective Creativity. Creative crafted to make deep, motivating connections with our target audience. We tap into psychology and combine that with creative craft and expertise and to deliver powerful, engaging work on a conscious as well as a subconscious level.
Blue Latitude Health
